Glynn Marshes writes:
Meanwhile, over at Metro, Eleanor Catton’s been thinking about elitism, literary criticism, and consumerism.
And yes, she’s standing atop the capital-L Literature bulwark, and yes, she’s wringing her hands — difficult to avoid when you’re an elitist defending elitism from the unwashed hordes. That said, she makes some good points about the way readers-as-consumers approach the task of so-called “book reviews:”
I spent some time this week trawling through customer reviews on Amazon and Goodreads, in order to look for trends — paying particular attention to the scathing one-star reviews that inevitably warn all other readers against buying or reading the disliked book . . .
Although there is a great deal of variation in the five-star reviews, the one-star reviews are overwhelmingly alike, even across genres and styles of literature. I noticed the recurrence of three principal objections: (1) this book was confusing; (2) this book was boring; and (3) this book was badly written.
“Confusing”, “boring” and “bad” are fine complaints, and in many cases may be pertinent complaints, but they are not criticisms. They are three different ways of saying that the work in question failed to evoke any response from the reviewer at all. Far from describing and critiquing a literary encounter — the job of criticism — such “reviews” only make it clear that a literary encounter never took place.
In other words, such reviews say more about the reader than the book.
She also dances near something related that, to my mind, is equally as interesting: that reviews are highly personal; that posting 1-star reviews is — perhaps primarily — a demand for validation:
The machine of consumerism is designed to encourage us all to believe that our preferences are significant and self-revealing; that a taste for Coke over Pepsi, or for KFC over McDonald’s, means something about us; that our tastes comprise, in sum, a kind of aggregate expression of our unique selfhood . . .
I freaking HATED that book, therefore I aaaaaaaaaammmmmmmmmmm 😉