Paleo Retiree writes:
I loved this well-done, labor-of-love, low-budget 2008 doc about child-abuse accusations in Bakersfield, California in the 1980s. The accusations all — let me repeat that: ALL — turned out to be false. Nonetheless, many of them resulted in innocent people spending years in prison, and many of them also blew apart families and friendships. The episode has also turned out to be historically important. It was the first in what became a long string of absurd, “believe the children!” cases that defined the era as much as its pop music and politics did.
Don Hardy and Dana Nachman’s movie doesn’t focus much on the big picture — on giving context, or on setting the stage, or on venturing explanations. For that you’ll need to look at a book, or maybe just read this excellent Wikipedia entry. What it zooms in on instead is the local and the particular: on the experience of the people who lived through the craziness, and on the repercussions of the trials and imprisonments. It’s also a neat look at Bakersfield — a town that kept re-electing its D.A. even after it became evident how wrong he’d been — as well as an immersion in a bizarre, not-so-long-ago period in American history when Satanic-abuse fantasies and recovered-memory zaniness were the order of the day. WTF was all that about?
The movie also got me wondering: Is the fanaticism about diversity, anti-racism and tolerance that we’re presently enduring a related form of shared nuttiness? And why does America put itself through periodic episodes of quasi-religious frenzy?
More
- The reporter Debbie Nathan did heroic work covering the Satanic-abuse scandals. Here’s her terrific book about the cases.
- Wikipedia’s summary of the Bakersfield case is a good one.
- An interview with the filmmakers.
- A look at the career of Bakersfield D.A. Ed Jagels.
- The film is available on Netflix — though, sadly, only as a DVD. Or you could buy a copy from Amazon.






